StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The films “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” (1944) and Pearl Harbor (2001) are two films about the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. This paper will compare the various details of these aspects within both the films and detail how film producers can create remakes that are unique and original…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.4% of users find it useful
Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor"

Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor The films “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” (1944) and Pearl Harbor (2001) are two films about the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor and the subsequent American bombing of Japan based on the book by Captain Ted Lawson, but they are vastly different in numerous areas. While the themes and characters are similar in both movies, the manners of expression within the movies differ in numerous ways. There are also similarities and differences in visual aspects of the movie, aspects of production, camera shots and angles, and mise en scene. This paper will compare the various details of these aspects within both the films and detail how film producers can create remakes that are unique and original. Although both of these films contain thematic content that has been the subject of numerous films, the writers, directors, and editors of “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” and “Pearl Harbor” have managed to create films that are unique and were considered great films of their time. The theme of the attack on Pearl Harbor is not a new theme for war movies and has been exemplified in other films, like “From Here to Eternity” (1953) and “Tora! Tora! Tora!” (1970) (Fischer). However, this theme is crafted in an original manner on the film “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo”. In this film, the soldiers are the primary focus of the movie and the actual events of the bombing of Pearl Harbor and the American response are secondary. This pattern is also mimicked in the movie “Pearl Harbor”. The lives of the nurses and soldiers before the bombing are detailed and this focus is maintained throughout the film, keeping the actual events of the battles as secondary themes. The storylines are also similar in that they focus on the romance between the soldiers and their ladies and the battles the soldiers endure are expressed as secondary storylines. The movies are more romantic than military in content and context, although they still present the military aspects in the context of battle scenes. The first hour of the movies “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” and “Pearl Harbor” emphasize the romances and civilian lives of the soldiers. However, “Pearl Harbor” also gives details about the lives of the nurses that were also in military service and were responsible for saving the lives of many soldiers and civilians. The battle scenes craftily interspersed with the romantic aspects of the films summarily remind the viewers that the films are about war. Although the movies were thematically based on the same topic, the characters in “Pearl Harbor” and “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” were completely different. Beyond the mention of ‘Jimmy Doolittle’ in “Pearl Harbor”, which was supposed to represent the primary character of ‘Lt. Col. James Doolittle’ in “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo”, the characters in the two movies were completely different (Crowther; Scott). Additionally, the romance in “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” was primarily centered around the romance between Doolittle and his wife, unlike “Pearl Harbor”, which also focused on the romances of several other characters. However, in both movies, the characters were supposed to represent commissioned soldiers that were called to fight for their country when the Japanese bombed the U.S. military base in Pearl Harbor, Hawaii. The portrayal of these every day characters added to the drama created by the plot and theme of the movies. The director of the movie “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” was Mervyn LeRoy and the producer was Sam Zimbalist. As the director, LeRoy was responsible for the direction of the actors and the direction the film took, specifically the restraint in the content of the film and the realistic portrayals of the characters (Crowther; Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 171). Based on the book of the same title that gives an account of the event from the perspective of Captain Ted Lawson, “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” is filled with moving scenes of human emotion and vivid portrayals of B-52 bombers making daring take-offs from the deck of aircraft carriers (Crowther). The battle action is exciting and thrilling with convincing performances from the actors and riveting cinematography that depicts realistic action. The romantic moments are captured with sensitivity and give the impression that the viewer is watching a private moment in the lives of real people. The scenes in “Pear Harbor” follow the same production method. Directed by Jerry Bruckheimer and Michael Bay and executive produced by Mike Stenson, the movie is set in the lush, tropical atmosphere of the Hawaiian Islands. Bay and Bruckheimer use this pristine setting to paint an idyllic picture of the abiding friendship between Rafe and Danny and the love between Rafe and Evelyn. Their romance is shattered when Rafe volunteers for a mission and he is MIA, but later returns only to discover that Evelyn has fallen in love with his best friend Danny. The drama of this love triangle is peremptorily put on hold when the thrilling formations of Japanese bombers bombard this idyllic setting, causing destruction and chaos in this pristine setting. However, “Pearl Harbor” does not allow for the same character development and the grace of the storyline is lost in the melee of underlying storylines like the love triangle between Rafe, danny, and Evelyn, and the smattering of real characters, like Dorie Miller, James Doolittle (Scott). Although the plot and storyline of “Pearl Harbor” could have used significant improvement, the cinematography and special effects made up for these missing aspects. Bruckheimer and Bay capture stunning aerial scenes and terrific images of explosions combined with exciting computer generated images that make all the dynamic imagery seem realistic. The tough-guy character of Rafe is illustrated with stunning flight scenes filled with lots of gun fire and the shy, sensitive character of Danny is depicted with the poignant love scene shared between him and Evelyn after Rafe is declared MIA. Unlike “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo”, the horror of the attack on Pearl Harbor is emphasized in the title picture and blatant images of the devastation caused by the Japanese attack are captured through brilliant sequences of the death and mayhem caused by the bombing. Dramatic images of the destruction of the docked ships with hundreds of sailors on board and buildings and people being blown to bits engage the audience visually and emotionally, bringing cheers of jubilation when the heroes fly off to avenge the lost lives of American civilians and soldiers. Both movies use various camera angles to engage the audience and present the desired impression. “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” was made in 1944 and the available cinematic devices used in “Pearl Harbor” were not available when “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” was created. However, “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” uses typical horizontal eye level, low level, and high level camera angles to capture numerous aspects of the action on screen (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 97). The angle of the camera is symbolic of the perception the director wishes the audience to have of the character, like if the camera appears to be looking up at the actor, it may be intended for the audience to see this character as someone to be admired (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 97). The film is shot in the 1.33:1 aspect ratio, as was typical during the 1940s and uses lenses of normal focal length and zoom lenses to capture close-up images of the characters in dramatic sequences (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 99-101). “Pearl Harbor” is captured with the use of much more sophisticated technology than what was used in “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo”. However, the camera angles used in “Pearl Harbor” are similar to those used in “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” with typical horizontal eye level, low level, and high level camera angles used to emphasize the personalities of the characters and embellish the drama of the story (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 97). The sophisticated technology available during the making of “Pearl Harbor” makes use of green screens and computerized imagery as well as live action to create a superior cinematographic experience. Wide angle shots capture picturesque images of planes flying in formation over green grasses and rolling hills as small children watch in awe and realistic special effects show massive explosions that seem to pop off the screen. The camera follows Japanese missiles specially fitted to traverse shallow waters as they plummet from the Japanese fighters and explode on the decks of unsuspecting American ships in riveting detail. Lighting, along with a variety of types of camera shots varying from extreme close-ups to extreme long shots all combine in “Pearl Harbor” and “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” to create powerful, emotional images that bring the shared story of Captain Lawson to life on the screen (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 85). In both films, the shots are specifically designed to keep certain aspects in focus to enhance the emotional aspects of the scene, like when Lawson says goodbye to his wife in “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” and when Evelyn sees Rafe again after thinking he was dead for several months in “Pearl Harbor”. Additionally, “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” uses lighting within the shots to enhance specific aspects in close-up and medium close-up shots (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 85). In “Pearl Harbor”, the colors are vibrant, depicting the use of saturation, while “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” is in black and white and shows the use of desaturation, which gives the movie a realistic look (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 95). Both films use framing to achieve a “combination of dramatic impact and aesthetic balance” (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 98). The cinematographer interprets and intensifies the elements of mise en scene and the lighting as they see fit to create the imagery according to the instruction of the director (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 87). The mise en scène includes numerous aspects of the cinematic experience, including the scenery, movement and positioning of the actors, props, the background, the blocking, and the intensity of the lighting (Goodykoontz and Jacobs, 87). The mise en scene in “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” accurately depicts elements of the time with costumes and numerous elements as does “Pearl Harbor”. However, the mise en scene in “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” is a bit more authentic, undoubtedly because the film was made during the 1940s when these elements were easily available and “Pearl Harbor” was made decades later. Despite these slight differences in the various elements of mise en scene, both films were able to accurately coordinate the various elements of mise en scene to present stunning, moving films. The contrasts between the visual aspects of the movie, aspects of production, camera shots and angles, and mise en scene within both the films have allowed the directors to create stunning remakes of the same material that is both distinctive and original. Although both of these films contain similar thematic content, “Thirty Seconds over Tokyo” and “Pearl Harbor” are unique and were considered great films of their time. Works Cited Crowther, Bosley. “The Screen: ‘Thirty Seconds over Tokyo’, a Faithful Mirror of Capt. Ted Lawson’s Book, With Van Johnson, Tracy, at Capitol”. New York Times 16 November 1944 Movie Review 22 Jul. 2011 . Fischer, J. “Top 7 Pearl Harbor Films and TV Mini-Series”. About.com. 22 Jul. 2011 . Goodykoontz, Bill and Jacobs, Christopher P. Film: From Watching to Seeing. 2011 California: Bridgepoint Education, Inc. https://content.ashford.edu Howe, Robert F. “They Turned the Tide: Members of the Doolittle Raiders Celebrate the 60th Anniversary of the U.S. Answer to Pearl Harbor”. Smithsonian Magazine-Smithsonian.com. August 2002. 22 Jul. 2011 . Pearl Harbor. Dir. Michael Bay. Touchstone Pictures, Walt Disney Studios Distribution, Gaumont Buena Vista International. Scott, A.O. “Film Review: War is Hell, but Very Pretty”. New York Times 25 May 2001 Movie Review. 22 Jul. 2011 . Thirty Seconds over Tokyo. Dir. Melvyn LeRoy. Metro-Goldwyn Mayer, 1944. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor Essay”, n.d.)
Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1578297-comparison-of-thirty-seconds-over-tokyo-and-pearl-harbor
(Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor Essay)
Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor Essay. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1578297-comparison-of-thirty-seconds-over-tokyo-and-pearl-harbor.
“Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/visual-arts-film-studies/1578297-comparison-of-thirty-seconds-over-tokyo-and-pearl-harbor.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Comparison of Thirty Seconds over Tokyo and Pearl Harbor

Pearl Harbour Paper

pearl harbor The Japanese imperial navy carried out surprise attacks on major USA installation at pearl harbor that had great implication on the region's political history.... America was exporting oil to Japan before the Japanese decided to attack the pearl harbor, this was a tactical method of controlling Japan.... If Japan had not invaded US installation at the pearl harbor, it would never become an energy independent nation....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Pearl Harbor Attack

(2000) “The pearl harbor Attack”, Guarding The United States And Its Outposts, CENTER OF MILITARY HISTORY, Washington, D.... This was the reason that the United States was pearl Harbour 7th December 1941: It was the day when the Japanese attacked pearl Harbour, a naval base of the United s of America.... Its simple, the Japanese became over confident and they changed their plans and instead implementing this defensive plan they went further to attack the US Midway....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Untold Story of Pearl Harbor

The author of the essay entitled "The Untold Story of pearl harbor" states that December 7, 1941, “…a date which will live in infamy…” is often quoted from President Franklin D.... Roosevelt's famous speech to Congress after the attack upon pearl harbor.... This paper will explore if Roosevelt did or did not covertly maneuver the United States into the Second World War and if he had access to information that could have prevented the attack upon pearl harbor....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Pearl Harbor Bombing

The paper "pearl harbor Bombing" describes that neither can the military and political establishment of the day be held totally responsible for the attack nor can the responsibility of such a massive blunder be laid on a few individuals.... hellip; pearl harbor put to rest the debate of the US joining or not joining the war.... Later 'Remember pearl harbor' became a universal theme in the wartime propaganda (Slackman, 1990).... Even prior to the transfer of Pacific Fleet from San Diego on the west coast in 1940, pearl harbor was under development as a major naval base....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework

Pearl Harbor Reflections

Perhaps one of the greatest questions of all time is this: why did Japan attack pearl harbor?... The United States also moved their pearl harbor base to Hawaii, from San Diego.... Feeling pressured by the demands of the United States, Japan's military force felt that the movement of pearl harbor from San Diego to Hawaii was a threat to their expansion throughout Asia and the Pacific.... With no settlements made on either side, the decision was made by Japan to attack the base in pearl harbor....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Mistakes from Pearl Harbor

As a function of such an analysis of the fundamental principles of warfare, t is the hope of this author that a better and more complete understanding of each can be appreciated by utilizing the lens of the Japanese attack on pearl harbor as a focal point to identify the failures of US strategy in preparing for and responding to such an attack.... The objective of the raid on pearl harbor was clear and evident.... Due to the fact that pearl harbor represented the highest concentration of American naval power in the Pacific region, an attack on such a target would yield a high level of reward for the enemy in that it could cripple the American ability to project force into the Pacific theater and held the potential of reducing the United States involvement in the Pacific to such a level that it would not be able to counter Imperial Japan's actions and acquisitions....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Battles of Pearl Harbor and Midway: American Intelligence Failure and Success

The writer of the assignment "The Battles of pearl harbor and Midway: American Intelligence Failure and Success" attempts to draw a contrast between the factors that led to failure and success in two of the most memorable American battles during World War 2.... hellip; The attack on pearl harbor and the Battle of Midway are among the significant naval confrontations in the history of America.... The attack on pearl harbor by the Japanese, that marked America's entry into WWII, aimed at preventing the United States from interfering with their military operations in South East Asia....
8 Pages (2000 words) Assignment

Validation of Structured Light Plethysmography before and after a Bronchodilator Challenge

The paper "Validation of Structured Light Plethysmography before and after a Bronchodilator Challenge" highlights that volume spirometry cannot be used for children below the age of six years, the lung diffusion capacity does not directly measure the main cause of hypoxemia.... hellip; DTW, applied in time series analysis, is an algorithm used in measuring the similarities which exist between two temporal sequences with variations in either time or speed....
38 Pages (9500 words) Research Proposal
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us