StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone de Beauvoir on the Woman as Other in Men's Representation - Coursework Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone de Beauvoir on the Woman as ‘Other’ in Men's Representation" paper argues that gender appears as a construct that takes into account primarily male ideas of the perfect woman. In this case, the role of the female body is ignored as having value itself…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone de Beauvoir on the Woman as Other in Mens Representation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone de Beauvoir on the Woman as Other in Men's Representation"

Simone de Beauvoir on the Woman as ‘Other’ in Mens Representation The relationship between sex and gender is of interest to many researchers. Scientists are trying to understand whether there is a relationship between biological sex and gender, and whether it is possible to equate these concepts. Simone Beauvoir offers an interesting concept. She seems to occupy a middle position between those who deny the link between sex and gender and those who fiercely defend it. According to her opinion, the biological feature of the male body allows men to automatically receive gender status as men: “a man never begins by presenting himself as an individual of a certain sex; it goes without saying that he is man” (Beauvoir, The Second Sex 15). Unlike men, women do not have such a possibility. The author draws attention to the fact that “one is not born a woman, but becomes one.” This means that, despite the uniqueness of the female body, women can become women only as a result of submission to established cultural norms and traditions in relation to femininity. A woman must prove that she is a woman and this is only possible if her behavior, appearance and even lifestyle will fit the male ideas of an “ideal” woman. Thus, according to De Beauvoir, feminine is not independent and depends on the preferences of men. Men determine the ideal of femininity that in turn makes the existence of women full of restrictions and abuses on the part of men in different areas of their lives. Beauvoir starts her research by regarding the stereotypes in relation to biological differences between men and women. It allows Beauvoir concluding that in a human society a womans body is considered as defective and limited, while the male body is always characterized positively. In fact, men see their bodies as having a perfect set of features for a happy life. In contrast to man, the “woman has ovaries, a uterus: these peculiarities imprison her in her subjectivity, circumscribe her within the limits of her own nature” (15). As the author notes, this stereotype in relation to the female body completely ignores the fact that the male body also has a number of physiological characteristics that define its functioning and, therefore, are specific limiters (15). In particular, similar to women, men have organs that produce a variety of hormones, including sex hormones. While the male body is regarded in a positive way as capable of connecting man with nature, the female body is seen as “as a hindrance, a prison, weighed down by everything peculiar to it” (15). Thus, a woman does not have a possibility to rely on her biological characteristics as an argument in favor of her femininity. The significance and high status of the female body is being denied. As a result, women are forced to find other ways to be recognized as women. In particular, women must conform to notions of femininity that exist in a given society. In turn, these perceptions are largely due to the fact that men perceive women through the opposition “Self - Other.” Beauvoir insists on the idea that modern society exists within the opposition between masculinity (“the Self”) and femininity (“Other”). The Other is treated as a foreign object, which should be subordinated to the authorities of the Self. Within this framework, the Self if represented by a man, while the Other - by a woman. In other words, a man sees a woman as his Other, which should be subordinated to his authority. Men may think of themselves without women, and women cannot do it. As a result, the woman “is defined and differentiated with reference to man and not he with reference to her; she is the incidental, the inessential as opposed to the essential” (16). Beauvoir notes that the existence of an opposition between Self and Other is determined by the characteristics of human thought, which contrasts the different objects: “Good and Evil, lucky and unlucky auspices, right and left, God and Lucifer” (17). The feature of this structure is that each of the elements considers its opponent as Other. The problem is that the concept of Other applies only to women, while it should apply to men as well. For some reasons, women do not seek to provide effective resistance against this system, while continuing to remain dependent on men. The author focuses on the practice of discrimination in the modern world. It is related to the fact that negative attitudes towards women and femininity cause certain social unspoken rules and regulations that limit the ability of women in various areas of their lives. Beauvoir points to the slavish dependence of women on men and insists that “at the present time, when women are beginning to take part in the affairs of the world, it is still a world that belongs to men - they have no doubt of it at all and women have scarcely any” (21). Discriminatory practices against women lead to the fact that men receive higher wages, take more long-term positions, and generally get much more opportunities for their self-development within the framework of modern society. Considering all of the above, Beauvoir asserts that A man would never set out to write a book on the peculiar situation of the human male. But if I wish to define myself, I must first of all say: I am a woman; on this truth must be based all further discussion. A man never begins by presenting himself as an individual of a certain sex; it goes without saying that he is man (15). Beauvoir gives a lot of evidence to suggest that a woman has always been subordinated to men, and men determined the gender status of women. In particular, Beauvoir analyzes the historical past of mankind. Beauvoir notes that in times of primitive societies women had some social weight and importance as they were responsible for gathering the fruits, plants, etc. Given that the main task of primitive people was to survive, the role of women had a higher value for the survival of a tribe. Nevertheless, with the development of tools that allowed men to hunt, the situation began to change dramatically. Further emergence and development of scientific technology have made it possible for men to consolidate their power over women, whose role has been reduced to childbearing and domestic responsibilities. “With the advent of patriarchy, the male resolutely claimed his posterity” (24). Patriarchal society strengthened the idea that man is the creator for his family and his children, while a woman should perform a secondary role as his faithful companion and wife. Despite the fact that the main mission of women was reduced to their physiological obligations in terms of the conception and birth of children, even this situation did not allow women to acquire the female status based on their biological differences from men. Motherhood as the primary biological destiny of women cannot help women receive their freedom as human beings. Motherhood does not give superiority to women, because it still remains the biological function of women (73). In other words, “nature does not define woman: it is she who defines herself by reclaiming nature for herself in her affectivity” (49). Practical oppression of women took place on a par with religious, philosophical and scientific ideas about the value of women and female. Since ancient times, women were seen as the object which should be subordinate to men, because they were attributed qualities such as passivity, inertia, confusion, weakness and infirmity. Even philosophers-humanists such as Aristotle viewed women as passive matter, which can be fertilized by an active male principle (25). The same representation of women and even worse can be seen in religious and mythological traditions of various cultures. In particular, Greek mythology considered the Mother Earth as the chaos that is devoid of order and full of dark and ugly monsters, creatures of the Goddess of the Earth (165). Christian tradition also demonstrates a negative attitude towards women by an example of the myth of the Fall. Eve is seen as the main culprit in the Fall of people because she persuaded Adam to bite the forbidden apple (185). Even many scientific studies have demonstrated contempt for the female body and its organs, seeing it only as pale shadows of the male body. Until relatively recently, “the ovary was ... regarded as a homologue of the male gland” (25). According to the author, modern scientific research and concepts are also characterized by the consideration of women and femininity through the prism of masculinity. In this regard, the main criticism falls to the psychoanalysis, as well as socialism of Marx and Engels. Beauvoir offers the reader a sufficiently detailed description of Freudian psychoanalysis. In spite of the practical value of psychoanalysis in the treatment of various mental health problems faced by both men and women Freudianism has one significant drawback. This drawback is that, similar to many other scientists, Freud ignores the individuality of womens sexuality. Freud points to the existence of libido as sexual energy, which plays a particularly important role in the lives of men and women. Nevertheless, libido regarded as having a male “character”. Freud “refuses to posit the feminine libido in its originality” (50). Thus, the separate existence of the female libido as a unique phenomenon, which cannot be fully compared with the male libido is denied in the theory of Fred. Beauvoir also gives a critical evaluation of the theory of socialism, because men and women are seen solely in economic terms as participants in the economic process. The tragedy of life for women is that in order to be “women,” the women must play certain roles, perform certain duties and obey the male preferences for feminine appearance, behavior, and even way of life. The fact is that for man the woman "is a sexual partner, a reproducer, an erotic object, an Other through whom he sees himself" (67). The woman thus is a means to meet the different needs of men, including sexual. She is only important as a means and as a method. Men do not want to be women, but they thank God for creating women (161). “The more women assert themselves as human beings, the more the marvelous quality of Other dies in them. But today it still exists in the hearts of all men” (161). "The real woman is the one who accepts her as Other” (273). Thus, the woman is a collective image of the qualities that are important for men. A woman should be modest, beautiful, young and healthy. She is a creature that embodies the very Nature for man, but she has no right to independent choice of way of life and behavior. Female gender is deprived of the right to determine itself based on biological characteristics of the organism. It depends on the cultural norms and rules established by men all over the world. As a result, “Beauvoir proposes that the female body ought to be the situation and instrumentality of women’s freedom, not a defining and limiting essence” (Butler, Gender Trouble 16). To sum up, Beauvoir proposes to consider gender in two ways: as pertaining to biological sex in the case of men, and as representing the theoretical construct in the case of women. Men initially have the opportunity to get the gender status as men, because no one disputes the link between their biological sex and gender status as men. In the case of women, the situation is exactly the opposite. Gender appears as a construct that takes into account primarily male ideas of the perfect woman. In this case, the role of the female body is ignored as having value itself, separately from men. On this basis, the female gender is capable of undergoing external changes primarily by men, who give it one or other necessary qualities (modesty, obedience, etc.). Beauvoir sees the task of women to break this tradition and gain their freedom of choice in the creation of their female image. Read More
Tags
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone de Beauvoir on the Woman as Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words - 1, n.d.)
Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone de Beauvoir on the Woman as Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 words - 1. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1850911-political-theories-of-sexuality
(Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone De Beauvoir on the Woman As Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words - 1)
Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone De Beauvoir on the Woman As Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words - 1. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1850911-political-theories-of-sexuality.
“Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone De Beauvoir on the Woman As Coursework Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 2000 Words - 1”. https://studentshare.org/social-science/1850911-political-theories-of-sexuality.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Political Theories of Sexuality: Simone de Beauvoir on the Woman as Other in Men's Representation

A Comparison and Contrast of de Beauvior and Kaufman

Says Kaufman, “It was simple: with rape, you tied the woman to a tree” (Kaufman, 1994).... The following essay is focused on the comparison of de beauvoir and Kaufman's concepts.... hellip; As the author of the text puts it, the key differential that exists between the authors is necessarily the fact that Kaufman and de beauvoir differ with respect to the level and extent to which the societal definitions should be sought to be changed.... However, Kaufman goes on to the state of this early representation of the way that societal interpretations impacted upon him; both then and now: “at that time the anatomical details were still a little vague; yet, it was still something ‘we' did” (Kaufman, 1994)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Analyzing the conditions of oppressed women according to Simone de Beauvoir's perception

Analyzing The Conditions of Oppressed Women according To simone de beauvoir's Perception Name: Tutor: Course: Institution: Date: Analyzing The Conditions of Oppressed Women according To simone de beauvoir's Perception Define what is sexual politics?... de beauvoir (1949) explains that men had acquired a higher position in industry and politics, thereby monopolizing principal positions.... Nonetheless, this has been a simple pursuit for people focusing on evading the strains involved in undertaking of genuine existence (de beauvoir, 1949)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Reflection on Beauvoirs Becoming a Woman

This illustrates Beauvoir's depiction of the woman as being the symbol of life where her main role will always be as mother, robbing her of her individuality expressed through her career, hobbies and general personality.... Towards the end of her book, Beauvoir restates that the woman's character is as a result of her situation and not vice-versa as would be expected.... This coupled with the fact that all the other women, my mother included, never at once objected to helping her but merely complained silently that that was life (de beauvoir 3)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Beauvoir's second sex

She emphasizes that in marriage setting the role of a woman as a house keeper/cleaner is evident of the servant hood role women are made to play.... Beauvoir says that is the target of religion and that it is pointless trying to prove whether a woman as treated in the society is inferior or superior because the man's situations has been made “infinitely preferable”.... According to Beauvoir, a woman is always full of worries but she has nothing to do to change her position, she cries, complaints, and even threaten suicide but she cannot escape her lot....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

The Power in Demography

simone de beauvoir, The Second Sex, 19492.... imone de beauvoir gained fame and established herself as an intellectual crusader with the publication of her book The Second Sex in 1949.... One wonders why there has never been a men's rights movement, it is because men do not need any such movement, rights are given to them on a silver platter by virtue of their gender.... While it is a fact that men are physically stronger, this doesn't mean they are intellectually superior to women in any way, thus discrimination against women at workplace or other areas is totally unfair....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Political Theories of sexuality

one can refer to the conclusions of simone de beauvoir.... As a result of thorough research Beauvoir came to the idea that such an opinion in relation to femininity and womens roles in society is due to the fact that a woman is regarded as other, that is a hostile object that must obey the will of men.... The German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche pointed to the fact that the Christian culture and morality based on it and presented in the Western world have a deep contempt for the individual human freedom in the choice of gender roles and ways to implement one's sexuality....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Personal Freedom and Others - Simone de Beauvoir

simone de beauvoir in Ethics and Ambiguity has used' Personal Freedom and Others' to describe the dissimilar views in which different people perceive and define freedom and how they either accept or deny it.... For instance, when says that each and every party started as a child with no right of freedom to choose Personal freedom and others simone de beauvoir in Ethics and Ambiguity has used' Personal Freedom and Others' to describe the dissimilar views in which different people perceive and define freedom and how they either accept or deny it....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Joan of Arc

Following her death, her memory was recovered and she has now entered into public consciousness through literature and various other sources.... The main focus of the paper "Joan of Arc" is on examining and trying to understand Joan's position as a woman in the fifteenth century and attempt to answer the question as to whether this position affected the different choices that Joan of Arc took.... This paper shall seek to understand her position as a woman in the fifteenth century and attempt to answer the question as to whether this position affected the different choices that Joan of Arc took....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us