StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Plea Bargaining Issues - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The essay "Plea Bargaining Issues" focuses on the critical analysis of plea bargaining issues. A plea bargain is a type of agreement in a criminal case between the defendant and prosecutor, in which the defendant of the case agrees to plead the guilty party to a particular type of charge…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.5% of users find it useful
Plea Bargaining Issues
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Plea Bargaining Issues"

Plea Bargaining Affiliation with more information about affiliation, research grants, conflict of interest and how to contact Plea Bargaining Define Plea Bargaining. A plea bargain is a type of agreement in a criminal case between the defendant and prosecutor, in which the defendant of the case agrees to plead the guilty party to a particular type of charge in return for some dispensation from the prosecutor. This may also denote that the defendant in the case will plead for a less grave charge or to any one of the numerous charges for the guilty party, in return for the discharge or dismissal of other charges. Sometimes the defendant also pleads for his client with the original criminal charge in return for a more lenient sentence. A plea bargain permits both parties to keep away from a long criminal trial and may permit criminal defendants to stay protected from the risk of conviction at trial on a more grave charge. For instance, suppose there is a defendant of a criminal case charged with a crime robbery, the conviction of which would need imprisonment in state jail, he or she may be offered the chance to plead the guilty party to a misdemeanor robbery charge, which may not carry jail time. Plea bargaining is “the process whereby a criminal defendant and prosecutor reach a mutually satisfactory disposition of a criminal case, subject to court approval” (Plea Bargaining 2012 para. 1). It can conclude a particular criminal case without a proceeding or a trial. It becomes successful when plea bargaining of the case results in a plea agreement between the defendant and prosecutor. In this agreement, “the defendant agrees to plead guilty without a trial, and, in return, the prosecutor agrees to dismiss certain charges or make favorable sentence recommendations to the court. Plea bargaining is expressly authorized in statutes and in court rules” (Plea Bargaining 2012 para. 2).  Distinguish between charge bargaining and sentence bargaining. Plea bargaining in fact involves three parts of negotiation. Charge bargaining and sentence bargaining are among the two elements of this negotiation. Charge Bargaining: This is generally a known type of plea. It engages a negotiation of the particular charges (counts) or offenses that the defendant of the case will face at the proceeding or trial. Generally, in return for an appeal of "guilty" to a smaller charge, the prosecutor of the case will dismiss the superior or other charge(s) or counts. Example, instead of discharging charges for a first-degree murder, a prosecutor may admit a "guilty" appeal for manslaughter. Charge bargaining plays an empirically significant role in determining outcomes of the sentencing. In this type of bargaining, the defendant of the case pleads guilty in exchange for reducing the charges. Depending on the seriousness of the initial charge of the case, the only one who stands to achieve from charge bargaining is the accused or the defendant for the reason that in some instances it can be the thin line between life and death. Sentence Bargaining:  Sentence bargaining engages the agreement to make an appeal of guilty (for the affirmed charge rather than a decreased charge) in return for a lighter sentence. It puts aside the prosecution, the need for participating in the course of trial or proceeding and proving its case. It offers the defendant with the chance for a lighter sentence. In sentence bargaining, the defendant of the case pleads culpable in exchange for a lighter sentence, which may consist of spending a shorter period in prison, probation, a counseling plan, or be placed in various types of rehabilitation center. • Compare and contrast the advantages and disadvantages of plea bargaining. The advantages and disadvantages of plea bargaining are quite obvious. They can be relevant to the individual defendant trying to decide if a bargain is the greatest method to go with. Lawyers on mutual sides of a criminal trial too accumulate advantages and disadvantages when they bargain. Essentially, the criminal method is influenced by plea bargaining also, in good and bad ways. When an individual is charged of a crime, there is a good chance that their lawyers will try their best to work out a deal. In plea bargaining, the defendant freely pleads guilty to a crime smaller than the one for which he has been charged.  When there is powerful data of a crime being committed, the person can be happy to admit to a less serious crime, other than the not guilty person may not be so satisfied. He would still claim fault for a crime not devoted and that could have serious consequences. The innocent person can opt instead to ask for a judge’s trial, other than that there may be effort from lawyers to avoid this, although eventually it is the accuser’s right to decide a plea. The lawyer of a defendant may be most persuasive if the plea denotes no jail time. Sometimes, even with no imprisonment, an innocent person might have just admitted to an offense that he or she did not commit. This can mean carrying an illegal record, paying huge amounts as fines or being on probation regardless of being innocent. There are a number of advantages or disadvantages of plea bargaining when it comes to criminal courts. These are overcrowded places that frequently welcome bargains because it means not having to plan a trial, which makes things a lot easier. However, it is also argued that there are problems when a lot of criminal cases being settled by plea, may not sometimes be dealt with justice and may be sidestepped with convenience. In countries right to a judge’s trial is seen to be sacrosanct, so the busyness of a court must not be measured. Some consider defending the innocent should never “plead down” and instead must always be given a judges trial. • Describe how plea bargaining reflects or thwarts the crime control and due process models of criminal justice. A plea bargaining is a contract in a criminal case whereby the prosecutor offers the defendant a chance to plead guilty, generally to a smaller charge or to a single criminal charge with a proposal of a lighter sentence. A plea bargain permits criminal defendants to avoid the risk of certainty at trial of the original more serious charge. For instance, a criminal defendant charged with a crime theft charge, the certainty of which would need incarceration in state prison, possibly is offered the chance to plead guilty to a wrong theft charge, which does not carry jail time. In case, for example, an automobile crash where there is a possibility for civil liability in opposition to the defendant, the defendant can agree to "guilty with a civil reservation" or plead no contest, which fundamentally is a guilty plea with no admitting civil liability. “Plea bargains reflect underlying systemic philosophy. In inquisitorial system countries, adjudication is seen more as a vehicle for policy implementation, which requires a determination of facts” (Strier 1994 pg. 213).  Plea bargaining could present a dilemma to defense attorneys, in which they have to prefer between energetically seeking a good deal for their current client, or sustaining a good connection with the prosecutor, for the sake of assisting future customers. Reference List Plea Bargaining (2012). The Free Dictionary. Retrieved from < http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Plea+Bargaining> Strier, D, Franklin (1994). Reconstructing Justice: An Agenda for Trial Reform. Greenwood Publishing Group. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Plea Barganing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Plea Barganing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1597475-plea-barganing
(Plea Barganing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Plea Barganing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1597475-plea-barganing.
“Plea Barganing Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1597475-plea-barganing.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Plea Bargaining Issues

Three Types of Plea Bargains

The process of plea bargaining is a private matter where only the accused, the defendant counsel, the prosecutor and in some cases the judge may be in attendance.... There are many advantages to plea bargaining as there are disadvantages.... Considering the success rates of plea bargaining compared to that of trials, the practice inadvertently aids in the reduction of criminals on the streets as well as guarantee speedy dispensation of justice (Goldstein, 1997)....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Ethics of Plea Bargaining

This term paper "Ethics of plea bargaining" presents current plea-bargaining structures.... thical Concern The plea bargaining system arose due to the increasing complexity, duration, and cost of criminal trials, and it gained importance due to the increasing use of adversary procedures based on the law of evidence (Chambliss, 2011).... As the criminal justice seeks to develop the plea-bargaining system, this focus on the prosecutor's discretionary powers, the victim, and the defendant is revisited....
12 Pages (3000 words) Term Paper

Benefits of Plea Bargaining

The paper "Benefits of plea bargaining" discusses that a few years back, the sentence purpose of plea bargaining was highlighted by its defenses, claiming that guilty convicts admitting the culpability benefitted with lighter punishments in comparison to those insisting on a trial.... plea bargaining is the procedure through which a person accused of an offense concurs to appeal for being culpable to a slighter crime in the switch over for a gentle punishment, a lessening of accuses, or further advantages....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Plea Bargains and Morality

orks CitedFreedom, Morality, plea bargaining, and the Supreme Court," Philosophy and Public Affairs.... There are multiple moral issues that arise regarding plea bargains.... There are multiple moral issues that arise regarding plea bargains.... The first has to do with the concern that plea-bargaining provides too much leniency for the guilty.... It's doubtful though, that plea-bargaining will ever be eliminated from our legal system completely, and it will likely remain important....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Plea Bargaining

The concept of plea bargaining has been established as a breakaway trajectory from the preexistent omnipotent system of jury trials.... Kentucky - 08-651 (2010) the court engineered in the substantive calculus of the notion of plea bargaining along with the attendants sentencing decisions, running of the lawyers along with the associated civil consequences.... Within the judicial system of the United States, the notion of plea bargaining is highly common with approximately 90% of the criminal cases being settled by plea bargaining mechanism rather than by the process of a jury trials....
25 Pages (6250 words) Research Paper

International Criminal Justice, Comparative Sentencing and Penology

The author discusses the impact of plea bargaining on trial justice and looks briefly at what plea bargaining is all about and when it is likely to be used.... From the perspective of the offender plea bargaining can result in shorter sentences and lesser charges for the crimes they have committed .... With judicial plea bargaining, the judge will give an indication to the defendant of the punishment he is minded to award if the defendant pleads guilty....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Plea Bargaining System

From the paper "plea bargaining System" it is clear that many find that plea bargaining allows the criminals to escape from the punishment which they deserve.... plea bargaining is subject to court approval and can vary according to state and federal laws.... American justice does promote plea bargaining where the judge acts in a passive role.... plea bargaining is a system in which the defendant pleads guilty for a lesser charge....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Criminal Process, Plea Bargaining and the UK

The paper "Criminal Process, plea bargaining and the UK" discusses that it is the commonly held opinion that in a legal system that assumes innocence and allows every person to go to trial; punishment for those found to be guilty after trial, is to be more stringent.... plea bargaining and abbreviated trials have emerged as the most popular techniques of alternative procedures.... plea bargaining is a process of negotiation, in which the prosecutor and defense counsel come to an agreement, wherein they attempt to resolve some of the criminal charges leveled against the defendant, without a trial....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us