StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Law of the EU - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The work "The Law of the EU" focuses on the significance of Article 45, and potential issues such as the right to freedom of movement for job-seeker people; after a failed marriage; for non-married partners; right to received allowances in another state. The author outlines the power of EU member states concerning extending the right to free movement of citizens…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.6% of users find it useful
The Law of the EU
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Law of the EU"

Law Law Introduction: It is a fact that the free movement of people is considered one of the most elemental legal provisions and frameworks of the European Union (EU). The economic and civil expedience underpins the sacrosanct nature of this freedom, so that it is impossible to sidestep it. Particularly, whereas free movement is integral to the realization of the market, it also provides people and their families to exercise the right to mobility. The flipside of this provision has been its penchant for predisposing member states to the inability to control entry and residence within their territory. Eventually, this has led to the member states’ attempts to minimize stemming the burden that unbridled movement of persons place on them. The Regulation EEC 1612/68 has already been applied to more than 2 million EU citizens exercising this right. In 1992, the Treaty of Maastricht created the Community model (amended Treaty of Rome), extended responsibility, and focused more on Community integration by exercising such rules. Originally, members of Community defined it as ‘economic activity’. However, this requirement has been abolished and under the new Directives, the nationals of the EU member’s state are classified as “Union citizens”1. Needless to say, the free movement of workers is secured2. This directly affects the EU member states by proposing and ratifying laws such as secondary law, Regulation (EEC) 1612/68, and Directives 2004/38. This essay will demonstrate and discuss the significance of Article 45, and potential issues such as (a) right to freedom of movement for job-seeker people; (b) right to freedom of movement after a failed marriage; (c) right to freedom of movement for non-married partners; (d) right to received allowances in another member states. Definition of workers: The definition of a ‘worker’ has a wider meaning as defined by the Community. However, it is not defined by the member of states3. For example, key case Lawrie-Brum4 concluded that a trainee teacher is a worker. It expanded the definition of a worker to a person who “for a certain period performs services for and under the direction of another person and in return receives remuneration”. This has given a broader interpretation of a worker, for example, if somebody works in a religious community he or she is still considered a worker5. This case law added further categories (i.e part-time chamber pupil6, part-time music teachers7, pacer in cycling race8, Professional footballer9); who were also regarded as workers because they engaged in an economic activity. The ECJ did not allow everyone because it restricts some categories under this broad worker definition. This is seen in the case of Bettray10. He claimed to be a worker while on drug rehabilitation programme. However, the ECJ declined to classify him as a worker because he was not engaged in any economic activity. However, scholars have heavily criticized it. 1.1 Job seekers: Article 45 (ex Article 39 TEC) gives the European Union citizens the right of movement from one union member nation to another in search of a job. However, Article 45 (3) subjects those rights to limitations because the state can derogate a person on the basis of the “public policy, public security, and public health”. Under the UK law, Procureur, 11an individual can be lawfully deported because he or she did not secure work within a limited time. However, the Court of Justice stopped a lawful deportation of an Italian job seeker12 by applying Article 45. Conversely, Aritcle14 (4) (b) of Directives 2007/38 allows citizens to enter into member states to seek for employment if they have genuine chances of getting a job. Nonetheless, the job seekers are not entitled to full benefits. Arguably, Antonissen13 and Collins14 confirmed this where the ECJ declined to give social security benefit because they were unsuccessful in looking for a job. In essence, this illustrates that citizens have the right to enter and reside in host country but, with some limits. 1.2 Family Directive 2004/38: EU has tried to resolve the problem that tries to harmonize the dynamics of free movement of persons within the Union. Directives 2004/38 gives the Union member state citizens the right to move from one state to another with his or her spouse15, registered partners16, children17and grandparents whom they have ‘durable relationship’ with. In order to stay, they are entitled for full beneficiaries’ status18and equal treatment19. In addition, the EU legislation prohibits discrimination based on nationality. This not only protects Union citizens from discrimination but also prevents non-EU nationals20 from discrimination. Divorce and separation: Before 2004, secondary legislation did not secure this right to divorced and separated partner Union citizens. Directives 2004/38 gives right to stay with their family even when separated. This is well demonstrated by Ditta21, a Senegalese married to a French national and lived in Germany but separated with her husband. She could not be deported because the ECJ allowed her to reside22 on continuing family link. In contrast, an Indian national did not gain entrance from the UK Boarder Agency because he separated with his German wife. Notably, he could not stay in host country because he was non-EU- national. As a result, the Court expanded family rights in Article 13 Directives 2004/38 and allowed non-EU national worker to stay in host country after separation. Despite the area being fairly restricted by four conditions laid down in Article 13 of Directive 2004/3823. 1.3 Non- married partner This is demonstrated by Ms Reed, a Dutch national, who had a stable relationship with her unregistered English partner and lived in Holland. She claimed for social benefit under Article 10 of Regulation No 1612/68 and won her case under Article 7(2) of Regulation because Dutch law allowed non-married partner to constitute social advantage rights. In this case, ECJ took a generous approach by ignoring the legislation ruling over Regulation1612/68 of Article 10, which states that an unmarried partner could not claim for same benefits as a ‘spouse’. 1.4 Non-discrimination rules: The EU legislation prohibits indirect and direct discrimination based on nationality. For instance, Article 18 TFEU addresses non-discrimination and citizenship within Union. In addition, Article 24(1) of Directive 2004/38 calls for equal treatment rights. This provision gives the worker’s family equal benefit in member states. Moreover, Regualtion492/2011 secures rights in specific areas such as rights of employment, housing, trade union rights and tax/social rights. In other areas there are also case laws that help reinforce European Union Laws that seek to modify movement. For example, there was the Comm v France (French Merchant Seamen)24, which makes specifications of non-discrimination on the basis of nationality. This case law was held by the European Court and held that there is not to be any form of direct discrimination on the grounds of origin25. In the case of Minister Public v Even the court specified that there should be limitation on those who access public resources, in accordance with their relationship with the European Union citizens. Ministere Public v Even rules that there should be the extension of benefits to the worker’s family, because by extending such benefits, the worker will also be benefiting, indirectly. While indirect discrimination was not allowed in the case of Ugliola, an Italian national who had offered national services in Germany and claimed for a pension on that basis and Germany refused to recognize his services. The ECJ held that in-direct discrimination on the ground of nationality within Union was not allowed. Under the rule exclusion of workers subjected in Article 45(3) of Directive 2004/38, a member state has the right to restrict free movement of people on the grounds of “public policy, public security, and public health”. For example, Van Duyn a Dutch national Scientologist wanted enter into UK but was not allowed on the basis of public policy, and went to court. The Court of justice held that this was an uninformed decision and decided against UK. This was heavily criticized by scholars because UK gives too much discretion power to the member states. In conclusion: It is true to remember that the Maastricht Treaty that integrates the European Community acknowledges the power of EU member states to exercise discretion26 concerning extending the right to free movement of citizens. This reflects on whether there is convergence between directives and Commissions decisions and the decisions taken by judges at the ECJ. However, a fundamental step taken on free movement of workers subjected Regulation NO 1612/68 to decreased bureaucratic formalities for Union citizens. Nonetheless, the general provision Directive 2004/38 removes obstacles of free movement to workers by giving them the right to enter and stay with their families without prejudice in member states. The ECJ seems to be a successfully resolved issue on case-by-case basis. Nonetheless, questions on the Community on whether there is a trend toward greater or lesser integration within Union still linger. This problem was portrayed when the Court of Justice declined jobseekers27 the right to social security benefits because they could not get employment. In essence, additional legislation could remove further barriers of movement, for example, pensions and students. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Law of the EU Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 13, n.d.)
The Law of the EU Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 words - 13. https://studentshare.org/law/1794445-law
(The Law of the EU Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 13)
The Law of the EU Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 13. https://studentshare.org/law/1794445-law.
“The Law of the EU Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1500 Words - 13”. https://studentshare.org/law/1794445-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Law of the EU

The Legal Contexts of European Union

nbsp;… Under these circumstances, it was held that was indeed within the ambit of the National Courts to provide the legal cloak that evolves from eu laws and to ensure the unambiguous enforcement of such laws.... Aggrieved, the petitioner took up this matter with Labour Court on the grounds that the subject clause in German Civil Code (BGB) which denies credit for the period below 25th year of service validity was void and “Paragraph 622(2) of the BGB is a measure which discriminates on grounds of age, contrary to European Union law, and must be disapplied....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

European Union Laws

This essay demonstrates the difference between persons who are established and those who are service providers within eu LAW.... There are some interesting examples of court practice concerning eu Directives application in cases of natural persons and companies.... The issue in this question requires an analysis on the distinction between persons who are established and those who are service providers....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

EU Dumping Determinations and WTO Law

the eu's anti-dumping policies are rationalized on the basis that they are necessary for removing harmful dumping on the part of foreign businesses and for maintaining fair competition in trade (Davis 2009).... Although the WTO's anti-dumping agreement is intended to allow member states to safeguard the interest of local producers and to ensure fair trade competition, both China and the eu have been known to use the WTO's anti-dumping agreement for excessive protectionism and for retaliatory measures (Davis 2009; Bolton 2011)....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

How has the EU-US Open Skies Agreement Affected EU Citizenship of Germany

The formation of the eu-US Open Skies Agreement, which had been signed in the year 2007 and became effective in the year 2008, can be duly considered as a historic decision, as it not only broadly supports the aspect of trade liberalisation but also promotes the development of better international trade as well.... This pact or treaty is popularly acknowledged as the eu-US Open Skies Agreement.... hellip; It can be apparently observed in this similar concern that the deregulation of the US domestic commercial based aviation business market eventually led the policymakers to explore innovative ways for the purpose of reducing the regulation of air transportation particularly between the US and the eu....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

FREE MOVEMENT OF PERSONS IN EU LOW

The cases of Defrenne v Sabena,1 Barber v Guardian Royal Exchange Assurance Group,2 and Marshall v Sotuhampton and South-West Hampshire Area Health Authority3, all portray instances of private parties looking to European Community (EC) law for assistance with their domestic grievances.... The revolutionizing case established the following conditions for the direct effect of EC law in the national courts of states: 'clear, negative, unconditional, containing no reservation on the part of the Member State, and not dependent on any national implementing measure....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Analysis of the ase Kolpinghuis Nijmegen BV

The facts of the particular case can be summarized as following: In Netherlands, the delivery of a beverage called ‘mineral water' has been considered as breaching the national law (the article 2 of the country's inspection regulation).... The reason is that the above… For this reason its delivery can be prohibited in accordance with the above mentioned national regulation where it is stated that the relevant authority has the power to prohibit the ‘stocking for sale and delivery of goods The case commenced in the Politierechter (Magistrate Dealing with Commercial Offences)....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

European Unions Law

Both cases involved the verdict given in accordance to BAfOG, Germany's Federal law on encouragement of… The first case was between Ms.... Morgan did not meet conditions on paragraph five, clause two that is 5(2) of the Federal law on encouragement of Education and Training BAfOG....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Direct Effects of the Directive

The Sale of Goods Act of 1979 requires the all goods sold to the buyer meet the description by being of satisfactory quality, description and must be fit for the purpose.... The transaction creates a contract between the trader and the client, and each party should treat the other… The effects of Act in case the goods do not meet any of those requirements is that the buyer has the right to take them back to the seller for replacement or repair within a reasonable time (Thies, 2013, p....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us