StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Is Criminal Behavior Determined Biologically - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The "Is Criminal Behavior Determined Biologically" paper supports the fact that genetic studies are at its very zenith today and that most diseases including some mental illnesses have a genetic disposition. However, when it comes to human behavior or the human mind…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Is Criminal Behavior Determined Biologically
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Is Criminal Behavior Determined Biologically"

Abdulkarim Almutairi CJST 4400 Russell Darlymple Feb 2nd Is Criminal Behavior Determined Biologically? In today’s times crime has become an extremely common issue that occurs on an everyday basis. Some of the crimes committed are serious while others are not and still others remain unreported. Each human being is different not only on basis of appearance but also with regards to socioeconomic status, background and thought processes. In spite of being vastly different from one another, humans tend to have common cravings for a good life that is free from problems and other stress factors. Perhaps, this very craving leads to crime itself. However I do not believe that crime is determined biologically since in the Nature versus Nurture debate I strongly support Nurture. Some do believe that crime has a genetic disposition but I believe that any person, irrespective of their biological or genetic background, when faced with certain stress factors can commit crime. Since the very beginning of the 20th century, several social researchers have reported that Blacks tend to commit more crimes when compared to their White or Asian counterparts (Piquero and Barme,2008). In fact official statistics also support this claim since and the racial minorities are regarded to be more genetically disposed towards crimes than other groups. In the recent years the field of behavioral genetics has conducted massive studies to understand whether genes and crimes are related or not. Race studies, adoption studies and twin studies have suggested that anti-social behavior is linked to the genes. Experts believe that since things such as gambling, drug abuse, risk-taking behavior and pleasure-seeking show evidence of genetic influence and since all of these behaviors have the potential to initiate crimes; one may suggest that crime and genes maybe closely related (Baker et al, 2006). In fact the field of forensic psychiatry supports the idea that chronic criminals have mutations in their genes which are hereditary in nature. According to this these mutations have an effect on the autonomic nervous system which in turn reduces an individual’s ability to learn normal social forces in inhibiting criminal behavior (Mednick and Finello,1983). On the other hand, with regards to the Nature versus nurture theory, I feel that nurturing has profound influence on one’s behavior. The environment and stress factors that an individual is exposed to, has a great deal of influence on his behavioral outcomes. Some of these stress factors are poverty and drug abuse. The constant association of Black minorities to commit crimes is overrated. In fact, Black and Hispanic neighborhoods are indeed more prone to crime than White neighborhoods but this is not attributed to their genetic make-up at all. Ulmer et al, conducted a study in 2012 where they analyzed census-place level data from California and Chicago and segregated White, Black and Hispanic population on basis of their social status and crime rate including homicide and violent acts. The results of the study showed that the difference in the crime rate between the racial minorities when compared to their White counterparts is due to their social and structural disadvantage (Ulmer et al, 2012). Next, the social structure and urban living conditions also contributes towards higher crime rate. A study demonstrated the complex relation between poverty, drug abuse and crime rate in U.S. localities. This study conducted by Valdez et al, investigated and established that in most U.S Urban areas, where community level poverty is high, individual level drug bause and crime rate is also high. Thus poverty and urban social structure are prime contributors towards drug abuse behavior as well (Valdez et al, 2007). In most cases, drug abuse behavior is followed by depression and other crimes which are ultimately a result of the several stressors that the individual was exposed to. Some twin studies do suggest that even in twins who are brought up in different environments show do share the common tendency to commit crime owing to their genetic similarity. However several studies have refuted this since acts of violence and antisocial behavior have been attributed as a complex interplay between genetics and environment. Tsuang et al conducted a study and established that in stark comparison to other twin studies where crime and genetic disposition positive inter-relation was established. In this study both twin (similar genetic make-up) and adoptee (non-similar genetic make-up) was done and the crime rate was analyzed. The results for both the subject groups was fairly equal thereby highlighting the fact that gene and environment have equal contributions to behavior (Tsuang et al, 2004). On a personal level I think, that since it is not possible to accurately understand the affect that genes and the environment has, one’s antisocial behavior may be attributed to both. I strongly support the fact that genetic studies is at its very zenith today and that most diseases including some mental illnesses have genetic disposition. However, when it comes to the human behavior or the human mind it is not possible for genes alone to work and influence one’s acts and I firmly believe that a man’s criminal behavior is not influenced by his genes. One of the most well known social psyhcologicsts B.F.Skinner had once said that he could turn a child into anything that he wanted. This is because children have a de-novo mind which can be influenced and shaped in any way and hence where a positive environmental can make a child become a lawyer, doctor or cop, a negative influence on the other hand can even turn a child into a burglar, drug abuser or alcoholic later in life. In stark contrast to the major belief that criminal behavior has a genetic disposition, I think that environmental factors play a more profound role. This is supported by the studies where it was proven that social structure, poverty and drug abuse are the major drivers of crime and since most minorities are both educationally and economically backward they have been unjustly related to crime as well. Moreover twin and adoptee studies have also shown equal crime rate thereby also highlighting the affect that one’s environment has on one’s behavior. Since, criminal behavior does have some common attributes such as poverty or criminal parents or environment, steps may be taken to educate children who are exposed to such stressors to help them cope with these drawbacks and make the right decision. Also, widespread education needs to be conducted in minority neighborhoods to allow them access to education and employment as well. References Baker,L.A. et al .(2006). Behavioral Genetics: the law of antisocial behavior.Law Contemp Probl, 69 (1), p.7-46. Mednick, S.A. and Finello,K.M.(1983). Biological factors and crime: implications for forensic psychiatry. International journal of Law and Psychiatry. 6 (1) , p.1-15. Piquero,A.R. and Brame,R.W. Assessing the Race–Crime and Ethnicity–Crime Relationship in a Sample of Serious Adolescent Delinquents.Crime Delinq, 54(3),p.390-442. Tsuang,M.T. (2004). Gene-environment interactions in mental disorders.World psychiatry, 3 (2), p.73-83. Valdez, A. et al (2007). Aggressive Crime, Alcohol and Drug Use, and Concentrated Poverty in 24 U.S. Urban Areas.American Journal of Drug and Alcohol abuse, 33 (4), p.595-603. Ulmer,J.T. et al.(2012). Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Structural Disadvantage and Crime: White, Black, and Hispanic Comparisons. Social Science Q, 93(3), p.799-819. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Is Criminal Behavior Determined Biologically Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/law/1679019-is-criminal-behavior-determined-biologically
(Is Criminal Behavior Determined Biologically Essay)
https://studentshare.org/law/1679019-is-criminal-behavior-determined-biologically.
“Is Criminal Behavior Determined Biologically Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1679019-is-criminal-behavior-determined-biologically.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Is Criminal Behavior Determined Biologically

General Perspectives on Human Behavior

biologically, human beings have an innate ability to form and maintain long lasting romantic relationships due to their genetic makeup while the environment too provides the learning experiences for individuals.... General perspectives on human behavior Name: Course: Tutor: Date: General perspectives on human behavior Romantic relationships exist between different sexes in human societies and there are about five general perspectives that explain how these relationships begin, develop, and maintained....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Physiological Factors of Criminals

To what extent do physiological factors explain why people become criminals Is it the extent to which physiological factors influence peoples behavior, and primarily whether or not they will become criminals This area is greatly influential within the nature/nurture debate, which is a core debate in psychology, as it looks at whether behavior is influenced by genetics more than by the environment.... To the criminal, the cost of a crime is the risk of punishment....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Factors which Create the Criminal

According to research findings of the paper “Factors which Create the Criminal”, without a sociological environment that supports, encourages, and teaches criminality, the biological disorders linked to criminality may not function to determine the development of criminal behavior.... The stated investigation, fortified by sociological, psychological, and scientific data, has determined that psychopathology, hence, criminality, is either a consequence of biological disorder whose effects are increased due to exposure to unhealthy social factors, or a result of social factors such as poverty, exposure to unstable and unhealthy family environments or violent communities which in turn, lead to the development of social pathology, or anti-social and destructive behavior (Horowitz, 1984: 95-96, 98)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Criminal Justice: Rationalism and Determinism

It has also been argued that these theories give a postulation that we cannot control crime by the fact that we cannot change criminal behavior in the population since it is genetic.... They can be explained in a simple fact as their postulation that crime traits are determined by some factors beyond individual control.... There have been studies that have been carried out suggesting that genetic factors and other biological harming aspects like head injury and exposure to toxic substances, and others may increase the chances of someone becoming a criminal by developing some criminal traits like impulsitivity and sensations seeking....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

In what ways do socio-biological theorists explain criminal behaviour

Many researchers are doing overtime to find out the causes of criminal behaviour.... But neither of these Order 441686 Topic: In what ways do socio-biological theorists explain criminal behaviour?... BiologicalPositivism is an extremely wide subject area, as wide as the scope of criminal behaviour is!... Many researchers are doing overtime to find out the causes of criminal behaviour.... But neither of these approaches proves conclusively about the criminal tendencies amongst individuals....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Influence of the Gut Bacteria on the Development of Brain

This paper will address the neurological factors and how they relate to criminal behavior.... This paper takes a look at the theory and how it impacts the study of criminal behavior in general and goes on to provides further evidence on the link between social behavior and microbial organisms.... The paper "The Influence of the Gut Bacteria on the Development of Brain" presents behavior and brain development.... he bacteria that often inhibit our intestines- the normal gut flora; have a significant impact on the development of the human brain and subsequent behavior as adults....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Proposal

Psychological and Biological Influences of a Crime

hellip; Various criminological theories have been advanced to explain the causes of criminal behavior, but modern criminologists combine aspects of psychology, sociology, biological theories and anthropology to advance their explanation on the causes of crime.... The theory assumes that human beings are rational actors and people make choices on either conforming or deviant behavior according to their rational calculations.... In this case, the state should maintain order through severe, certain, and swift punishment that is essential in controlling human behavior (Stucky & Krohn 2009)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Can Everyone Become a Criminal

This paper "Can Everyone Become a Criminal" tells that the study of criminal behavior is a large branch of social science and forensic psychology.... hellip; In the 1960's the use of psychologists in making predictions of dangerousness and criminal behavior and verifying pleas of insanity in criminal court cases gained prominence and added weight to this branch of social science that saw the discipline widely acknowledged in legal studies and increased acceptance of theories....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us