StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Martin Luther King vs. Malcom X Debate - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
On one end, Martin strove to bring peace and unite people by preaching a message of peace while Malcolm was ready to apply any means necessary in order to prove his point (Keith and Anissa…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.2% of users find it useful
Martin Luther King vs. Malcom X Debate
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Martin Luther King vs. Malcom X Debate"

Martin Luther King vs. Malcolm X Debate Martin Luther King and Malcolm X were two great men who led people using different means. On one end, Martin strove to bring peace and unite people by preaching a message of peace while Malcolm was ready to apply any means necessary in order to prove his point (Keith and Anissa 33). This entails that, their reasoning, arguments, and support for their message was different. Their debate is very essential in today’s literature studies. Particularly, most of the things discussed in their speeches are of great essence to contemporary, historical studies.

This paper intends to give the essence of the debate between Martin and Malcolm and state specific points of disagreements between the two. Finally, the paper will take a neutral stance based on their arguments. Arguably, there is noticeable indifference in Martin’s way of leadership especially in cases where he talked about Civil Rights. In his quest for Equal rights to all people, Martin deliberated for a non-violent protest, passive resistance, and use of what he termed as the “Weapons of love”.

With reference to these protesting means, it is seeable that Martin’s fight for Civil Rights involved simple and friendly methods. On the other end, Malcolm X was a great leader, but unfortunately, his means of fighting for Civil Rights were rather outrageous than those of Martin Luther King. At some point, analysts point out that Malcolm X was suspicious of the whites and was ready to apply “any methods necessary” in order to achieve equality (Keith and Anissa 48). Additionally, the debate between these two great leaders is very substantial as it gives the best understanding of weapons used by leaders during activism.

The video of King and Malcolm shows that, as long as he strove to achieve what he felt best for his people, Malcolm was a segregationist up until his renowned pilgrimage to Mecca since he was a Muslim. In the video, Martin’s reasoning was rather rationale unlike that of X whose arguments depicted uncertainty in various occasions. For instance, before his highly spoken departure to Mecca, X’s attitude towards racial discrimination against blacks depicted rather uneven correspondence with that Martin.

As such, his Black Muslim brothers, under the royalty of Elijah Mohammed, revolted and started viewing X as a threat to the Black Muslim Movement. Specifically, the debate between Martin and X shown profound disagreements with regard to the arguments, reasoning and quotes brought about by both leaders. In the case of Martin, struggle for Equality for Blacks sought to employ non-violent, peaceful means just as Martin said in the video that the fight for Civil Rights should “speak out for non-violence”.

X’s means and reasoning was rather violent one since he was ready to use “any means necessary” to liberate African Americans from inhumanities that faced them (Keith and Anissa 57). In conclusion, I find the debate between X and Martin as educative and crucial to the current studies of African American struggle for liberation or freedom and ethnic studies. In my view, Martin’s arguments and support for his reasoning was substantial and sought to establish a figurative leadership among other.

Otherwise, X’s state of arguing and reasoning highlighted violent means where he would do anything, according to his speeches, to achieve his goal (Keith and Anissa 81). To some extent, his arguments appear self-centered and egocentric instead of seeming decisive. Nevertheless, this paper has resolved to bring about the essence of the debates held by these two great men, Martin Luther King and Malcolm X and highlighted the disagreements within and among their arguments, reasoning, and support.

Then, concluded by taking a stance with regard to their speeches.Works CitedKeith, Gilyard and Anissa, Wardi. African American Literature. New York, NY: Penguin/Pearson, 2004. Print.King, Martin and Malcolm, X. Web, November 20, 2012.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Martin Luther King vs. Malcom X Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1609115-martin-luther-king-vs-malcom-x-debate
(Martin Luther King Vs. Malcom X Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/history/1609115-martin-luther-king-vs-malcom-x-debate.
“Martin Luther King Vs. Malcom X Debate Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1609115-martin-luther-king-vs-malcom-x-debate.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Martin Luther King vs. Malcom X Debate

Contemporary Diversity Issues Paper

For example, while the Civil Rights movement of the 1950's/1960's, whether the peaceful one organized by martin luther king or the more militant one as represented by Malcolm X sought equality for African-Americans, such equality often did not extend to the women involved in the movement....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The Civil Rights Movement in the American South

Above all, conceivably, in Payne's opinion, the top-down elucidation promotes a triumphalism that marks off black fundamentals as a fringe anthology of ingrates, overlooking that by the end of their lives, "the gap between martin luther king's thoughts" and that of Malcolm X was "less than one might imagine" (p....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

If Barack Obama Was Assasinated

Comparing Obama to both martin luther king Jr.... and malcom x, there is a strong case made that any black politician that events so strongly into society is eventual taken care of.... For the first time we have both an African American and a female candidate on the Democratic side, and this has sprung to new life the debate over racism and sexism in politics....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Malcolm X and Martin Luther King's Methods of Struggle for Rights of the Underprivileged

The essay “Malcolm X and martin luther king's Methods of Struggle for Rights of the Underprivileged”compare radical and peaceful ways to fight for civil rights.... During the Civil Rights struggle, Malcolm X preached a more militant stance, while martin luther king advocated a non-violent struggle....   The (F)Utility of Violence: martin luther king and Malcolm X It would have been easy to accept violence as a solution in the struggle for equal rights by a people that had been oppressed by centuries of slavery....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Strategies Used to Strike a Blow

martin luther king Jr.... martin luther king Jr.... martin luther king Jr.... Civil society largely respects nonviolent means such as discussion, communication of ideas, and debate to solve social problems through a political method.... When he organized from a religious base, it was not from the mosque in the same degree as king, but nevertheless, his pilgrimage to Mecca and the Nation of Islam are examples of the inseparability of religion from his philosophy of resistance....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Summary of Ten Readings

In all aspects, it was Third World Marxism proved to be the best framework for converting ideologies of greats like Malcolm X and martin luther king into an ideological revolution.... Seattle became the home ground of protests in the US, before that, it was Chicago, the capital of protests against the Vietnam War. It is equally important to understand… What needs to be understood in clear form is the changes brought by the protests in the 60s, be it against racial discrimination or against sending troops to Vietnam, they took a Third world Marxism paved the way for a multiracial movement from what developed as a deeply segregated U....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Differences between Race & Gender

This essay, Race and Gender, declares that all men and women were created equal.... The creator further made them to be happy and enjoy certain rights altogether.... During the course of life, man is required to serve more than one purpose other than his normal duty.... hellip; According to the study the rights of all are defined and dictated by the government of the day, which means that if this government does not provide as required by them, then the people are mandated to change the government....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The book report about "" Foner, Eric "The Voices of Freedom" Vol. I ""

In America, we can see this struggle through such monumental figures as martin luther king and Fredrick Douglas.... This leads to civil unrest such as the ones advocated for by the African Americans in the 1950s and 60s and highlighted by sensational leaders such as Fredrick Douglas, martin luther, and Malcolm X.... ne can conclude that there is a great need for debate and understanding of the needs and themes that affect all major societies, especially in this day and age through literature such as voices of freedom this debate that started two centuries ago has not ended, merely changed, and will not stop until the fundamental principles are reached in our societies....
2 Pages (500 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us