StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

'Stalin blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Cold War Instructor Name Joseph Stalin has been, without doubt, one of the most impactful influences in the shaping of power relations in the contemporary world politics. A centrally crucial figure to the cold war, his personality and its impact on his politics is magnetic for historians, drawing them into a debate that has been raging for decades – was the enigmatic Stalin directly responsible for the Cold War or was he a victim of the sociopolitical context of the time…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.5% of users find it useful
Stalin blundered into the Cold War. Discuss
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "'Stalin blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss"

Download file to see previous pages

Indeed, there are facets of the Cold War debate over which many of the contemporary scholars are in agreement, particularly with reference to Stalin’s paranoid personality. The focus of this study, however, is a matter of contention amongst eminent Cold War historians. Whether Stalin blundered into the Cold War out of a confusion and misjudgment of his adversaries’ intentions that derived from his suspicious personality, or whether the reality of an aggressive US foreign policy nurtured Stalin’s existing paranoia, thus forcing him into an unavoidable conflict will be one of the central themes of discussion.

Taking into account and critiquing the work of prominent Cold War historians, this essay will serve to evaluate the origins of the Cold War with particular reference to Stalin. The study aims to demonstrate that Stalin greatly overestimated the US desire for war, and blundered into the Cold War as a result of his paranoia and obsession with personal and domestic security. Looking at the Cold War through the lens of Gaddis, Matsny, Zubok and Pleshakov, a conclusion can be drawn towards how the Cold War originated from miscalculation and lack of judgment on part of Stalin.

John Lewis Gaddis is one of the most influential post revisionist historians of the Cold War. In his book titled We Now Know, he clearly does not see Stalin as blundering into the Cold War. In fact, he is seen as a conscious initiator of the events that led to it, while the US is represented as merely reacting to the threatening desire Stalin held for world domination. Influenced by “Marxist Internationalism” and “Czarist Imperialism”1, Stalin had a personality that was conducive to paranoia and insecurity.

It is this fusion of ideologies, coupled with an insecure personality that led to the Cold War. Gaddis therefore, sees Stalin’s ideology as a key figure in the Cold War. In its essence, Gaddis sees the Cold War as an ideological war between America and the Soviet Union, where American pluralist democracy and capitalism is argued as inherently superior to Soviet communism, and is the cure to the threat of a communist world. American historian Vojtech Matsny offers a distinct insight into the Cold War, and addresses one of the integral issues that Gaddis conveniently overlooks.

In The Cold War and Soviet Insecurity, Matsny revolves around the figure and personality of Stalin, and his preoccupation with maintaining his autocratic rule. Stalin’s imperialistic approach towards rule deflects through his paranoia and insecurity that eventually led him into the Cold War. Aware of the lack of popular support his regime had, Stalin intelligently chose to cash in on the 2fundamental Bolshevik belief that “the outside world remained implacably hostile”. Carefully carving out a sense of “us” and “them” through help of the revolutionary communist ideology, Stalin’s prime objective was to preserving his regime and maintaining power within the Soviet Union rather than world domination.

As Matsny argues, Stalin did not deliberately wish for a Cold War, but considering his Soviet ideology and insecure imperialism, could not avoid it. For Matsny therefore, “

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“'Stalin blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/history/1466134-ychstalin-blundered-into-the-cold-waryie-discuss
('Stalin Blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss Essay)
https://studentshare.org/history/1466134-ychstalin-blundered-into-the-cold-waryie-discuss.
“'Stalin Blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/history/1466134-ychstalin-blundered-into-the-cold-waryie-discuss.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF 'Stalin blundered into the Cold War.' Discuss

Aftermath of WWI and the Treaty of Versailles

The leaders of the victorious allies pinned the majority of the guilt and all the wickedness of the Great war on Germany.... At that time it was not a far fetched dream.... The leaders who crafted the agreement was assured that it was the best thing for everybody.... With the League of nations backing up all the treaties of peace being… But as always the conquerors can spare little compassion for the vanquished specially if the enemy was as powerful and as dominant as Germany....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Explaining the American Renaissance Paper

The newly born nation was desperate to get a new identity for itself which would be totally free from European influence.... This desire… The Americans felt the time has come when they need to speak in a voice which indeed was their own, use an idiom and forge an expression that truly reflected the uniqueness of American nation....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Art History Final Paper

How does the structure support the tenets of Buddhism?... What is a Stupa and from which Hindu form is the shape and decorative elements derived? The Stupas are arranged to form hemispherical domes… There are four curves of the gateway that faces four directions of the railings.... The Stupas have stone fencings as the railings and staircase make decorations....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Effects of Media Advertising on the Markets of Dolce and Gabbana

Its product quality and services are praiseworthy, but its command over domestic and international markets is mainly brought about by controversy-driven advertisements.... Overemphasizing on ad campaigns for building a consumer base… In this paper, I identify the influence of advertising on businesses and consider Dolce & Gabbana as the central subject of this analysis....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Operations Uranus and Mars: World War II Russian Strategies

hellip; World war II was one of the bleakest moments in the history of mankind and at the same time one of the most militarily interesting in terms of strategies employed by Hitler's Third Reich, and the Allied forces.... This essay will attempt to provide some understanding as to why Operation Mars has been obliterated from all historical sources save for a few....
24 Pages (6000 words) Essay

Churchills Key Elements of Strategic Outlook: Technological Innovation and Military Transformation

This paper discusses that Winston Churchill was a better leader than Benito Mussolini because of his military strategies, speaking and writing skills.... Churchill was a colourful personality.... Due to lack of parental attention, he was a lonely child who translated his loneliness into imaginations....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study

Churchills Speeches During World War II

… Churchill's Speeches During World war IIA soldier, writer, artist, and statesman— all rolled into one, Sir Winston Churchill is undoubtedly one of the greatest leaders of Britain for all time to come.... His exploits during World war II have won him Churchill's Speeches During World war IIA soldier, writer, artist, and statesman— all rolled into one, Sir Winston Churchill is undoubtedly one of the greatest leaders of Britain for all time to come....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Organized Criminal Organizations in the United States

The Outlaw Motorcycle gangs were originally born out of disaffected of disaffected World war II veterans returning home to find society did not understand the terrible things to which they had been witness and therefore no longer fit into mainstream life.... The original bikers were not a criminal group but rather free spirits in pursuit of the thrills that war had given them and no longer available in conventional society; however, this innocence was short lived as a series of conflicts with the police dramatized in the film the Wild Ones marked the beginning of outlaw status....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us