StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Big Dig - an Unprecedented Massive Engineering Project of Boston - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper presents the Massachusetts Big Dig. This is an unprecedented massive engineering project for an urban renewal of Boston, designed to bring underground interstate highway. It is assumed that it will improve the urban environment by spurring economic development of nearby areas…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.5% of users find it useful
Big Dig - an Unprecedented Massive Engineering Project of Boston
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Big Dig - an Unprecedented Massive Engineering Project of Boston"

MASSACHUSETTS BIG DIG (A case perspective analysis) Introduction (description and statement of facts) The Massachusetts Big Dig is an unprecedented massive engineering project for an urban renewal initiative by the city of Boston. The main aim of this project is to put underground or to “bury” an existing major and very busy interstate highway through downtown Boston by the use of a tunnel. This project can be considered a success from the viewpoint of improving quality of life and the urban environment by spurring economic development of nearby areas adjacent to its former Central Artery (I-93) which were previously already showing signs of decay. The barriers created by the above-ground highway had been eliminated and now replaced with a green space which in turn revived the inner-city parts of Boston by significantly improving vehicular traffic and human or pedestrian traffic by vastly simplifying traffic circulation with positive impacts on public transit as well. However, the total project costs exceeded original estimates by five times due to poor planning; underground drilling was undertaken while the project had already started such that actual sub-surface conditions were not known earlier, resulting in unpleasant surprises. Discussion (from the viewpoint of various perspectives) A really big or ambitious project like the “Big Dig” deserved more thorough engineering studies prior to starting the work but for some reasons (most likely urgency due to the congestion at Boston City), an initial environmental impact study (EIS) began in 1982 was quickly followed by an earmarked funding in 1987 by Congress with the amount of $755 million allocated for the said project to start in 1991 but by the time it was finished in 2005, actual costs exceeded initial cost estimates and reached $15 billion with another $7 billion to be paid for the additional bond payments by the city. In other words, this project was started with very little planning and done almost in an ad-hoc basis or what is termed as muddling through, hoping it will turn out right. Ethics Perspective – public officials pushing for the Big Dig Project should have taken into account the ethical consequences of an ill-conceived project of this magnitude. In other words, they should have first considered the ethical implications of spending huge amounts of taxpayers' money which in retrospect, diverted precious funding from other equally important public works. The cost overruns and the continuing payments for the increased debt load of the city of Boston cannot adequately compensate for the enormous fiscal burden incurred by the Big Dig Project on the city's inhabitants including all future generations of the citizens of Boston. It does not speak well of their fiscal responsibility to safeguard city funds for any worthy projects. Obviously, only some sectors of the city were favored over other less vocal sectors. But on the other hand, there were also other competing considerations and obligations in this case. City officials are also mandated to look after the welfare of city residents and one of its primary concerns was the growing traffic congestion in a high-density population urban area like Boston. Something has to be done now before the problem gets any worse when it will become more difficult to solve. The ethical obligations of city officials were to find a logical solution but at the least cost to the city treasury while minimizing any potential disruptions and aggravations. Public officials thought of urbanism as a creative political act on their part and so found an outlet for this creativity through a botched massive engineering project (Inam, 2013, p. 235). Accountability Perspective – there seems to be no one who was found to be primarily or mainly liable for the huge cost overruns of the project and there seems to be no public outcry on the way the city spend its funds. Once the project had started, it was already difficult to stop it or even pause or defer it until such time all detailed engineering plans and studies were completed. The money just kept pouring in and getting spent on the big project (Greiman, 2013, p. 146). In the Big Dig, the public officials and others involved in the project were accountable for the overall budget (to ensure it will stay within budget), project financing (where to source the funds for the project), and adherence to project criteria such as safety, reliability and also the project completion (that there will be no delays that will unduly hinder the project's timetable).It failed on most of the criteria listed above, such as safety due to numerous accidents and the large excess costs of the project from its original cost estimates. A lesson from this case is the need for a governance board that will oversee all these various concerns (ibid.) and see to it all competing interests like political, project, social, and corporate structures are all aligned to one aim. Prevention Perspective – the best prevention method to avoid problems in any really big project is to appoint or require a centralized governing board of directors which well try to bring together multiple governance structures to avoid any probable conflicts of interest that may arise. This governance board will have ultimate responsibility for the strategic plan of the project and in addition, also develop a framework for it by making a list of the key success factors (KSF) by which to measure actual performance of project contractors including all sub-contractors. This board will also grant the levels of authority for each project proponent and easily allow it also to pinpoint accountability and responsibility in case something goes wrong (Wald, 2006, p. A17). Political Perspective – before the Big Dig Project was even conceived by two engineers named Bill Reynolds and Frederick P. Salvucci, the prevailing sentiment of city residents was a cross between anger and resignation to their fate of growing and worsening traffic congestion; it was predicted if nothing was done about the chronic congestion due to bad design of the original expressway (Interstate 93 or I-93), then traffic jams of up to sixteen hours would become normal. City executives, local businesses, and residents were all agreed something drastic has to be done. There were also pockets of public opposition to the project coming from those sectors of society who will most likely suffer adverse consequences. In a particular example, some areas or neighborhoods subjected to exercise of the state power of eminent domain will have to sell and vacate their residential properties to give way to the project at a time when property values were quite high in a highly-urbanized center like the city of Boston. Other residents hoped something will correct the grievous error that was I-93; what convinced most Boston residents to go along with the project was the belief Big Dig will be a triumph of engineering (Williams,2006, p. 707) together with sensible and logical urban planning that will somehow save downtown Boston. Bureaucratic Perspective – any big city will have its fair share of fierce advocates and on the other side, equally vociferous opponents for any project because each side will find a strong justification for their respective positions. While the state governor and city executives had both approved the project concept, business leaders wanted a different project that will provide faster access to Logan Airport and furthermore, while appropriations were passed by the Congress, it was later disapproved by Pres. Reagan as too expensive but the U.S. Congress overrode his veto. To circumvent expected bureaucratic delays (red tape), the Massachusetts Turnpike Authority (MTA) was created that later on took joint-venture partners but caused problems with regards to the role and responsibility of the MTA to supposedly independently monitor project partners. Conclusion (lessons learned from the Big Dig) Any big project offers unique challenges and demands so no two projects can be the same but creation of a governing board is always a necessity. Both the public and private sectors must cooperate to ensure project success. Project administrators and contractors must abide by a code of ethics through ethical conduct consonant with professional morals (Cooper, 2012, p. 71). Reference List Cooper, T. L. (2012). The responsible administrator: An approach to ethics for the administrative role (6th ed.). Hoboken, NJ, USA: John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. Greiman, V. A. (2013). Megaproject management: Lessons on risk and project management from the Big Dig. Hoboken, NJ, USA: John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated. Inam, A. (2013). Designing urban transformation. New York, NY, USA: Routledge. Wald, M. J. (2006, November 2). Late design change is cited in collapse of tunnel ceiling. The New York Times, A17. Williams, R. H. (2006, July). The Big Dig. Technology and Culture, 47(3), 707-711. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(Big Dig - an Unprecedented Massive Engineering Project of Boston Term Paper, n.d.)
Big Dig - an Unprecedented Massive Engineering Project of Boston Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/engineering-and-construction/1828046-massachussets-big-dig-case
(Big Dig - an Unprecedented Massive Engineering Project of Boston Term Paper)
Big Dig - an Unprecedented Massive Engineering Project of Boston Term Paper. https://studentshare.org/engineering-and-construction/1828046-massachussets-big-dig-case.
“Big Dig - an Unprecedented Massive Engineering Project of Boston Term Paper”. https://studentshare.org/engineering-and-construction/1828046-massachussets-big-dig-case.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Big Dig - an Unprecedented Massive Engineering Project of Boston

Business Strategy in Global Environment

The company has a very strong organisational culture in place, which is perfect for handling any unprecedented circumstances in the company's external and internal environment.... Executive Summary: Fastway is New Zealand's primer courier and parcel delivery company.... This company came into existence 1983, and since then it has gone on to become world's largest franchise courier services company....
17 Pages (4250 words) Assignment

Corporate NGO Partnerships In Developing Countries

Restructuring of the society with efforts being made for the welfare of the state has led to massive growth of NGO s in Western countries.... All big personalities, students, model or people from any other profession had a great deal of support for a popular campaign named as “Make Poverty History”....
25 Pages (6250 words) Essay

Safety Practices in the Saudi Arabia Construction Industry

Since this growth, Saudi Arabia has faced an unprecedented construction boom, as its infrastructure has undergone massive development including the erection of new cities, airports, public and private buildings, highways, etc.... project Plan, Methods and Techniques 24 3.... project Plan 24 3.... The paper "Safety Practices in the Saudi Arabia Construction Industry" states that the relevant qualifications of the author include a degree in Mechanical engineering....
29 Pages (7250 words) Case Study

An Unsound Economy - Americas Socio-Economic Gap and the Coming of the Great Depression

Name Class Instructor Date An ‘Unsound Economy': America's Socio-Economic Gap and the Coming of the Great Depression The 10-year period between the end of World War I and the great stock market crash in 1929 was a period of transformative socio-economic change unprecedented in U....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Performing arts business management marketing in Asia

The performing arts are increasingly facing competition from newer modes of entertainment like the movies, portable media like cds and dvds, online content, outdoor sports, theme-parks and popular music.... With the economic and demographic changes there has been a change in… The customers have become more demanding in terms of the experiences and services that they desire in return of their time and money....
40 Pages (10000 words) Essay

Opportunities and Challenges of E-commerce Development in China

hellip; According to the study, e-commerce in China has grown at an unprecedented rate since 1993.... It is not very hard to estimate how big this market can be.... big businesses are realizing the potential of e-commerce and names such as Walmart are gearing up to seize this opportunity....
21 Pages (5250 words) Essay

Discovery of Crude Oil and Development of the Industry

The paper “Discovery of Crude Oil and Development of the Industry” focuses on the existence of an energy crisis in Nigeria.... The oil crisis is evident when one learns that the country, one of the world's top producers and exporters of crude oil, has profited more than $300 billion from Nigeria's oil....
40 Pages (10000 words) Research Paper

Political, Economic, and Social System of Qatar

This coursework “Political, Economic, And Social System of Qatar” intends to review who represents executive and legislative powers, whom Emir appoints, what are the powers of Advisory Council and Council of Ministers, and what has changed with the adoption of the new constitution of 2005....
31 Pages (7750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us